文学城论坛
+A-

用英文接着问:what would be the verdict if this happens in the US s

Bailey4321 2025-04-06 09:59:28 ( reads)

Great question! If this situation were brought to a U.S. small claims court, the judge would likely look at:


Key Legal Considerations

  1. Was there a clear agreement or obligation?

    • A agreed to let B bring the ring to school — likely informally.

    • B voluntarily accepted responsibility, making her a sort of “bailee” (someone temporarily holding property for someone else).

  2. Was B negligent?

    • If B lost the ring because it was loosely worn and fell off, the court would ask:

      • Was that a reasonable way to carry it?

      • Did B take basic precautions to protect someone else’s property?

  3. Value of the ring

    • The court might ask for proof of the ring’s value to assess damages.


? Likely Verdict

In many small claims courts, the judge might rule that:

So the judge could:


In Legal Terms:

This is a classic case of “bailment with slight negligence” — B had a duty to protect A’s property and arguably didn’t do so adequately.


Want help turning this into a mock argument for debate or a class activity?

跟帖(0)