文学城论坛
+A-

APAD: Might makes right

移花接木 2024-02-24 05:19:47 ( reads)

Might makes right

Might makes right or Might is right is an aphorism on the origin of morality, with both descriptive and prescriptive senses.

Descriptively, it asserts that a society's view of right and wrong is determined by those in power, with a meaning similar to "History is written by the victors". That is, although all people have their personal ideas of the good, only those strong enough to overcome obstacles and enemies can put their ideas into effect, and spread their own standards to society at large. Montague defined kratocracy or kraterocracy (from the Ancient Greek: κρ?τος, romanized: krátos, lit. 'might; strength') as a government based on coercive power, by those strong enough to seize control through physical violence or demagogic manipulation.

Prescriptively (or normatively), the phrase is most often used pejoratively, to protest perceived tyranny.

The phrase sometimes has a positive connotation in the context of master morality or social Darwinism, which hold that a society's strongest members should rule and determine its standards of right and wrong, as well as its goals for the greater good。

 

跟帖(37)

最西边的岛上

2024-02-24 06:19:26

And Might might not be democracy?

移花接木

2024-02-24 07:59:48

American Democracy rose, British Colonialism down after WWII

移花接木

2024-02-24 08:00:33

democracy is mighter

移花接木

2024-02-24 07:53:53

right, might is absolutely prescriptive, might or might not

最西边的岛上

2024-02-24 09:03:37

I know. ;-)

7grizzly

2024-02-24 08:52:17

Good to learn 'kratocracy,' though not a dictionary word.

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 08:59:45

统治阶级说了算。Learned a lot of new words. “master morality”什么意思?

7grizzly

2024-02-24 10:05:54

Might be just prevailing morality, perpetrated by the ruling

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 10:50:50

你的词也好难,越发看不懂了:)

7grizzly

2024-02-24 13:31:26

Sorry. I just meant popular morality.

移花接木

2024-02-24 16:28:28

which might is which?

移花接木

2024-02-24 10:06:42

prescriptively right! 大概就是指master阶层的morality, 说法来自尼采,同理

移花接木

2024-02-24 10:07:33

slave morality

7grizzly

2024-02-24 13:13:07

Good to know!

移花接木

2024-02-24 15:56:20

打倒尼采

7grizzly

2024-02-24 16:55:16

What for? What did the poor guy do? :-)

移花接木

2024-02-24 17:20:54

master,slave违背社会主义核心价值观

7grizzly

2024-02-24 17:38:59

Okay. 罪名可以是“寻衅滋事” :-)

最西边的岛上

2024-02-24 18:03:29

FYI:尼采在中国(1902—2000)(for fun reading ;-)

7grizzly

2024-02-24 18:41:39

thank you! Good to know his impact. I like a few quotes

移花接木

2024-02-24 10:09:28

看看这一段

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 10:49:23

一上升到哲学高度,觉得英文好难:)

移花接木

2024-02-24 11:11:01

一句话,Noble的人配拥有master morality

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 11:35:36

master morality是统治者道德观吗?“prescriptively right”是规范者正确?还是规范者权利

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 11:36:23

prescriptively是形容词还是副词?什么意思?

移花接木

2024-02-24 15:52:07

might makes right, 如果你说它是:力量决定正义,这就是Descriptive,相当于直意

移花接木

2024-02-24 15:54:57

might makes right 如果你说它是:利用强势欺负弱势,这就是Prescriptive,字面没说但有此含义

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 20:10:51

奥,有点metaphor的意思~ 这两个词很有意思,绝佳的押韵对称

最西边的岛上

2024-02-24 11:12:22

哈哈,对我来说,哲学就是难!有好玩时候,也有脑袋大想逃跑时候,out of sight out of mind ;-)

妖妖灵

2024-02-24 11:33:49

哈哈,我实在是不懂。我也不怕人笑话,今天大拿们都在,正好搞明白点:)

方外居士

2024-02-24 11:32:52

拳头大的有理。力強者有理。

盈盈一笑间

2024-02-24 12:53:44

社会达尔文主义还蛮冷酷的

方外居士

2024-02-24 14:20:43

是啊,东方哲学不崇尚力强者胜,西方哲学则确实如此。justice is power

移花接木

2024-02-24 16:04:57

东方哲学?包括日本了吗?东方哲学虚伪,不这么说事实确如此

方外居士

2024-02-25 08:28:59

中国哲学。确实中国的这一套虚伪。所以历代实际上都是儒表法里!

盈盈一笑间

2024-02-24 13:03:23

想到俄乌战争了, 今天是2周年。在楼上跟一个新闻。

godog

2024-02-24 15:46:51

So, Mr. Right is Mr. Might?